Book a Call Contact Us Get Your Business Growth Plan
Succession Planning

When AI Does the Routine Work, Who Becomes Your Next Partner?

Many accounting firms are living with a quiet irony. The AI tool that saves a first-year associate four hours on a bank reconciliation may also take away the four hours in which they would have learned to spot what is wrong with it.

AI is good news for busy firms. But it is also changing, faster than most partners realize, how future partners are made.

Key takeaway

AI now handles the reconciliations, tick-and-tie, data entry and first-draft returns that once taught junior accountants professional judgment. Research shows AI improves a beginner’s output, but it can weaken their learning if there are no guardrails. Firms that want future partners now need to design that learning on purpose instead of leaving it to chance.

Why does it matter that AI is taking over junior accounting work?

For generations, accounting has trained people through repetition. A junior ticks and ties hundreds of figures, reconciles dozens of accounts and drafts returns that a senior marks up. Through that volume of work, judgment forms: a sense of what “normal” looks like, and an instinct for when something does not add up.

I saw this in my own corporate career. I worked on business cases, financial models and presentations, and I would hand a printed draft to my manager for review. It came back covered in red pen. Then we sat down together, and I learned why each change mattered. I reworked it, and it went to the senior manager, and then to the partner. Each review reshaped the document. By the end, it often looked very different from my first draft, and much better. Each reviewer added their view of what needed to be said, and what needed to be done, in that situation. That room and that red pen are where I learned judgment.

The profession now says this learning model is under pressure. A September 2026 Thomson Reuters Institute analysis says the traditional on-the-job learning model is breaking down, because hybrid work, automation and offshoring are taking over routine tasks. In the same analysis, Carl Mayes of the AICPA asks how a junior can know “what good looks like” without ever doing the work.

Canada’s profession saw this coming. In its 2022 Competency Map 2.0, CPA Canada stated that “many traditional entry-level CPA job opportunities are changing and/or disappearing” because of automation. CPA Ontario’s 2025 Annual Report adds that AI is “putting a far higher premium on critical thinking and professional judgment.”

Is AI actually reducing entry-level accounting jobs?

Yes, in the UK and the US, though AI is one cause among several.

  • UK Big Four graduate intakes fell. Accountancy Age reported that KPMG UK cut its graduate and school-leaver intake from 1,399 to 942, about a third. Deloitte cut its intake by 18%, EY by 11% and PwC by 6%. Graduate job listings in accountancy were down 44% year on year.
  • PwC is hiring fewer juniors on both sides of the Atlantic. PwC UK reduced its entry-level intake from 1,500 to 1,300 in 2025, according to Fortune. In the US, an internal PwC presentation projected 2,197 tax and assurance associate hires in 2028, 1,045 fewer than in 2025. It named “the impact of AI” as one reason, alongside transformation work and offshore centres.

AI is not the only cause. PwC UK’s chief named the economic slowdown as the biggest factor and expects junior hiring to rise again. Offshoring and cost pressure also play a part.

Does using AI help or hurt how junior staff learn?

Both. It depends on how AI is used, and this is the most important point for any Managing Partner.

AI lifts performance, but it can make people confidently wrong. In a Harvard Business School and BCG study of 758 consultants, those using GPT-4 on suitable tasks finished 12.2% more tasks, 25.1% faster, with more than 40% higher quality. But on a task outside what AI does well, AI users were 19 percentage points less likely to get the right answer.

AI without guardrails can harm learning. In a University of Pennsylvania study published in PNAS (June 2025), nearly 1,000 high-school students practised math with or without GPT-4. Students with open access did better in practice, but once the AI was taken away, they scored 17% lower than students who never had it. A tutor version that gave hints instead of answers largely removed that harm.

Trusting AI too much can reduce critical thinking. A Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon survey of 319 knowledge workers found that more confidence in AI went with less critical thinking. More self-confidence went with more of it.

Some juniors get better results with AI, and some get worse. In a KPMG and University of Texas at Austin study of 523 early-career KPMG professionals, staff were asked to improve on work the AI had already done. About half did better than the AI on its own. About a quarter only matched it. The rest made the AI’s work worse, even though they had similar knowledge and skills. The difference was how they worked with the tool, not how much they knew.

Designed well, AI speeds up learning. In a Harvard trial published in Scientific Reports, 194 physics students learned more than twice as much from a purpose-built AI tutor as from an active-learning class, in less time. The tutor made students try each step first.

I see a pattern here. AI that hands juniors the answer improves today’s work but weakens tomorrow’s judgment. AI that makes them think first can do the opposite.

How does this create a succession problem for accounting firms?

Succession depends on people who can one day own client relationships and make judgment calls. That pipeline was already under strain before AI arrived. It may get worse in the coming years if firms don’t change how they develop their people.

  • Canada: Federal projections from the Canadian Occupational Projection System show 32% of financial auditors and accountants were aged 50 or over in 2025, with about 55,400 retirements expected by 2035. Overall supply is rated “balanced”, so Canada’s challenge is less about headcount and more about experience and succession. CPA Canada reported 4,188 candidates passed the September 2025 Common Final Examination.
  • United States: The AICPA’s 2025 Trends Report recorded 55,152 accounting degrees in 2023–24, down 6.6% from the year before. Enrolment is now showing signs of recovery, but the Thomson Reuters Institute, citing Bloomberg, notes the US still has 340,000 fewer accountants than in 2019.
  • Partner readiness: Inside Public Accounting’s 2025 report found only 55% of firms surveyed, mostly larger ones, have a written succession plan for their Managing Partner, and 31% of Managing Partners are over 60. An earlier AICPA survey found 57% of multi-owner firms had no written, approved plan.
  • Selling to private equity: CPA Trendlines tracked 104 private equity deals in accounting in 2025, up from 22 in 2023. For many owners, an outside buyer is becoming the plan because no one inside is ready.

Here is where AI comes in. If the next group of staff spends fewer years doing the work that builds judgment, the gap between “senior associate” and “partner who can own the client” gets wider. Firms with 5–25 people feel this most. They rarely have a deep bench, and losing one future partner can change their exit options.

What are the large firms doing about it?

The largest firms are redesigning how juniors learn, not giving up on it.

  • Deloitte UK rebuilt its three-year audit graduate program from September 2026. Trainees now practise on simulations, using both traditional and AI-assisted auditing, before they join audit teams (ICAEW).
  • AICPA guidance, summarized by the Thomson Reuters Institute, describes one large firm that cut technical training time in half and replaced it with critical-thinking exercises. Others use slow periods for practice on real-world return types.

None of this needs a Big Four budget. It needs intent.

How do you train junior accountants in the age of AI?

Train them to think before they use the tool, and to explain what the tool produced. Here is a practical framework for a firm of 5–25 people.

1. Manual first, then AI. For each core task, such as reconciliations, accruals, a T1 or T2 return or a review file, have new staff complete a set number by hand before they use AI. This matches the Penn finding: practising without help builds the skill that later checks the tool.

2. “Explain the output” reviews. Replace “Is it right?” with “Walk me through why it is right.” The junior explains what the AI produced, what they checked and what they would challenge. This is the modern version of the red pen.

3. A written competency map. List the eight to twelve judgment skills a future partner in your firm needs, such as skepticism, materiality calls, client communication, scoping and pricing. Review each person against them every quarter. What people once picked up informally now has to be made visible.

4. Capture partner judgment before it retires. Write short “why I decided this” notes on unusual files, and turn recurring decisions into SOPs and case studies. These become your firm’s training library.

5. Give juniors the full context, early. Use the time AI frees up to bring juniors into client meetings, planning calls and debriefs.

Looking back, my best learning in any corporate role came when I had the full context. Early in my career, partners took me to client meetings. They forwarded me the emails and notes, and they briefed me on the conversations I had missed. I knew what I was doing and why I was doing it. That context matters even more today, and it is also the secret to getting good results from AI. Give AI the full picture and it can do remarkable work. Juniors are no different.

6. Train your managers to coach. Managers carry most of the coaching load and are often the least trained for it. A weekly 30-minute one-on-one focused on decisions, not task status, is one of the cheapest succession investments a firm can make.

7. Name your bench and write the plan. Identify two or three potential successors, the gaps between them and partnership, and a dated plan to close those gaps. The next section shows how to start.

How do you start succession planning for an accounting firm?

Start early, start with people, and write it down. A practical sequence:

  1. Decide what you want, and when. A full exit, a gradual step back, or staying on in a smaller role? Put a target date on it. Every other decision depends on this one.
  2. Look at what your firm depends on. How many client relationships rest on you alone? How much of the firm’s knowledge lives only in your head? These are the risks a successor, or a buyer, will see first.
  3. Name your potential successors. Assess them against your competency map and be honest about the gaps.
  4. Transfer relationships, not just files. Introduce successors to key clients years ahead, and let them lead meetings while you are still in the room.
  5. Put it in writing. Update your partnership agreement, buy-out terms and timeline with your lawyer and a business valuator. Review the plan every year.

Should I sell my accounting firm to private equity?

It depends on what you want, and on whether you have a real internal alternative. Private equity is now a serious option: CPA Trendlines tracked 104 private equity deals in accounting in 2025, up from 22 in 2023. Most activity involves larger firms, or larger platforms buying smaller firms as add-ons.

Before you decide, ask yourself:

  • Do I want a full exit, or do I want to keep working, and on whose terms?
  • How will my clients and my people be treated after the sale?
  • What happens to my role, my decision-making and my independence?
  • How much of the price is paid upfront, and how much depends on future results?
  • Is there someone inside the firm who could buy in instead?

A developed bench helps either way. It gives you a real internal option to compare with any offer, and buyers look closely at how much a firm depends on its owner. This is a major decision, so get independent legal and financial advice before you commit.

Is AI the reason succession will be hard?

No. AI speeds up a problem that already existed. Pipeline pressure, ageing partner groups and thin benches came before AI. What AI changes is the margin for error. When the routine work that once trained people disappears, firms can no longer rely on time and volume to produce their next partners. They have to develop them on purpose.

The firms that handle this well will be the ones whose leaders take developing people as seriously as they take a client file.

If you are thinking about how your firm develops its next leaders, or what your succession options really are, I am always glad to talk. Learn more about our leadership development for CPA firms or book a call.

Book a call

Frequently asked questions

How do I start succession planning for my accounting firm?

Start by deciding what you want and when: a full exit, a gradual step back or a smaller role. Then identify which client relationships depend on you alone, name two or three potential successors, and assess their gaps against a written competency map. Introduce them to key clients years ahead. Put the plan, buy-out terms and timeline in writing with your lawyer, and review it every year.

Should I sell my accounting firm to private equity?

It depends on your goals and whether you have a real internal alternative. Private equity deals in accounting are rising; CPA Trendlines tracked 104 in 2025, up from 22 in 2023. Before deciding, consider how clients and staff will be treated, your future role and independence, and how much of the price depends on future results. Get independent legal and financial advice.

How do I train junior accountants in the age of AI?

Have juniors complete core tasks by hand before using AI, then ask them to explain and challenge what the AI produced. Keep a written competency map, record how partners make decisions, and bring juniors into client meetings early so they understand the full context. Give managers a weekly coaching rhythm focused on decisions, not task status.

Will AI replace junior accountants?

Not entirely, but it is changing what they do. UK Big Four firms cut graduate intakes by between 6% and about a third, and PwC US plans 1,045 fewer associate hires in 2028 than in 2025. Most firms are reshaping junior roles toward reviewing AI output, using judgment and working with clients.

How does AI affect how junior accountants learn?

It depends on how it is used. A 2025 PNAS study found students using unrestricted GPT-4 scored 17% lower once the AI was removed. A tutor version that gave hints instead of answers largely avoided that harm. AI that thinks for juniors weakens learning, while AI that makes them think first can strengthen it.

Why is succession planning harder for accounting firms because of AI?

Succession depends on developing people who can own client relationships and judgment calls. AI removes much of the repetitive work where those skills used to form. At the same time, only 55% of firms surveyed by Inside Public Accounting have a written succession plan for their Managing Partner.

What are large firms doing to train junior staff with AI?

Deloitte UK rebuilt its audit graduate program around simulations that combine traditional and AI-assisted auditing from September 2026. Other large firms have replaced some technical training with critical-thinking exercises and practice on real-world cases.

Is the accounting talent shortage the same in Canada as in the US?

Not exactly. Canada's federal projections rate supply as balanced through 2035, but 32% of accountants and auditors were 50 or older in 2025, with about 55,400 retirements expected. Canada's challenge is mainly experience and succession. The US has a sharper shortage of graduates.

Sources

  1. Thomson Reuters Institute, “How accountants learn judgment in the age of AI” (September 2026)
  2. CPA Canada et al., Competency Map 2.0 (2022)
  3. CPA Ontario, Annual Report 2025
  4. Accountancy Age, “The Big Four’s new favourite grad is AI” (June 2025)
  5. Fortune, PwC UK entry-level hiring (September 2025)
  6. CFO.com, PwC US campus hiring plan (August 2025)
  7. City AM, “PwC expects junior hiring to push back up across professional services”
  8. Harvard Business School Working Knowledge, BCG “jagged frontier” study (2023)
  9. Bastani et al., “Generative AI without guardrails can harm learning,” PNAS (June 2025)
  10. Lee et al., “The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking,” Microsoft Research / Carnegie Mellon, CHI 2025
  11. Harvard Business Review, “Research: Why Some Junior Employees Work Well with AI—and Others Don’t” (July 2026)
  12. Kestin et al., “AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning,” Scientific Reports (June 2025)
  13. Employment and Social Development Canada, Canadian Occupational Projection System — Financial auditors and accountants (2026–2035)
  14. CPA Canada, Common Final Examination results
  15. AICPA, 2025 Trends Report (October 2025)
  16. Journal of Accountancy, “The accounting graduate pipeline: Where do things stand?” (October 2025)
  17. Inside Public Accounting, “Succession Planning and Generational Shifts: Is Your Firm Ready?” (October 2025)
  18. AICPA PCPS, CPA Firm Succession Planning Survey, multi-owner firms (c. 2020–21)
  19. CPA Trendlines, private equity investments in CPA and accounting firms, 2020–2025 (November 2025)
  20. ICAEW, “How Deloitte is reshaping its audit training for the AI age” (March 2026)